Thursday, 27 April 2023

How old is my Portable Rock Art?

Patina depth vs time chart for dating flint artifacts
Patina depth vs time (indicative ranges only)

How to Date Portable Rock Art: Methods, Limits & Practical Tips

Portable rock art can be dated using a mix of physical, chemical, and contextual evidence. No single test “proves” an exact year; instead, we triangulate a timeframe from patina growth, stratigraphy, tool typology, and, where conditions allow, laboratory methods such as TL/OSL, U/Th, ESR, or radiocarbon of associated organics.

For background on object types and terminology, see: Portable Rock Art (overview), Figure Stones (guide), and Eoliths (deep antiquity).

First: Prove It’s Art, Then Date It

Before dating, establish human agency. Otherwise, you may end up dating weathering films, bird poo, or random fractures. Look for: repeated motifs (faces/animals/hands), deliberate removals and retouch, consistent striking angles, symmetry, pigment recipes, patina continuity across scars, and critically assemblage context with similar pieces and tools in the same material.

Example of analytical confirmation: FTIR (diamond ATR) showing intentional pigment recipe 

Dating Methods (What Works & Where It Struggles)

Patina Depth & Hydration Layers

Flint microstructures hydrate; patina thickens over time. Use measured thickness (µm) against reference curves for relative age brackets. Excellent for screening; ranges get broad with extreme antiquity. See: Dating Flint Artifacts with Patina (chart & notes).

Interpretive Dating via Iconography & Fossil Comparisons

Some researchers attempt to date portable rock art by interpreting the imagery itself, such as comparing animal depictions to species known from the fossil record. For example, a carving resembling a mammoth might suggest a Pleistocene context. However, this approach is highly subjective and open to bias; without corroborating stratigraphy, patina, or scientific testing, iconographic comparisons alone should be treated with caution.

Comparative Typology & Assemblage Correlation

Compare flaking strategy and forms to known industries (Oldowan, Acheulean, Mousterian, microlithic). Works best when finds sit in a coherent assemblage. Note: archaic techniques can persist or reappear later.

Luminescence (TL / OSL)

Thermoluminescence dates last heating; OSL dates last sunlight exposure under burial. Powerful but lab-based and context-sensitive. Dates the last event, not creation.

Radiocarbon (Indirect Organics)

Dates organics in pigments/binders or overgrowing crusts (if present). Useful <50k years; contamination risk; many flint pieces lack organics.

Uranium–Thorium (U/Th)

Dates calcite/mineral accretions formed after the art gives a minimum age. Requires suitable deposits and closed-system behaviour.

Electron Spin Resonance (ESR)

Measures trapped charges in quartz/silica; can reach deep time when conditions are right. Specialist method with dose-rate assumptions.

Stratigraphic / Contextual Dating

Layered geology (and co-occurring fossils) can bracket age if the find is truly in situ. Surface finds lose most of this power.

Rock Varnish / Manganese Accretion

More common in arid-zone petroglyph studies; thickness/chemistry can provide minimum ages. Variable growth in temperate settings.

Tar / Bitumen Encasing

Organic tar/asphalt can sometimes be radiocarbon or chemically dated, yielding strong minimum ages if the artifact is encased.

Spectroscopy (XRF / FTIR)

XRF profiles elemental residues (pigments, oxides); FTIR (diamond ATR) identifies binders and organics. These are not clocks but can link to specific environments or biogenic sources that support chronological interpretation.


Further Reading & Resources

FAQ

  • How can I tell how old my portable rock art is?
    Combine patina measurement, stratigraphy, typology, and if conditions allow lab methods (TL/OSL, U/Th, ESR, radiocarbon of organics). Cross-checking matters more than any single test.

  • Can I date a stone at home?
    You can measure patina and compare typology to known industries; absolute dates require labs and controlled sampling.

  • What’s most accurate?
    Luminescence, U/Th, ESR, or radiocarbon (for organics) are strongest in the right contexts; each measures a different process, so results can differ.

  • How old can portable rock art be?
    In some contexts, potentially millions of years (Tertiary); elsewhere, tens of thousands. Context, patina, and stratigraphy are key.

  • Does patina prove great age?
    Thick, continuous patina across scars is strong evidence of antiquity, but growth rates vary with environment; treat as relative dating.